Oh, yes, this applies not only to apostates, but also to ‘infidels’ (that’s us).
…The third and final guest, Dr. Abdullah, was somewhat critical of the first two Islamic scholars—not because they called for the man’s death, but because, by focusing on the fact that the man had apostatized, it seemed as if they were exonerating non-Muslims: “The issue of killing him is not limited to his being a Muslim and then apostatizing. No, it is known to us from the Sharia that whoever insults the Prophet or tears the Koran, his judgment is death—whether he’s a Muslim or non-Muslim.”
Later, a listener called in saying, “Just so you know, if I ever meet one of these people, their life is void—they’re simply dead.” The talk show host, who agreed that the man must be slain, responded with some moderate talk about letting the state handle such people, to which the first sheikh, Dr. Mahmoud Sha’ban, erupted in rage:
“Man, we’re talking about the religion of Allah! The religion! The religion!! The woman who insulted the Prophet, he voided her life! There were ten people at the conquest of Mecca whose lives the Prophet also voided!”
When the host tried to get a word in, the cleric exclaimed: “I am the sheikh, not you. I am the sheikh, not you! I am the sheikh! Hear me to the end, before I get up and leave!!”
Dr. Abdullah tried to mediate by clarifying to the host: “Do you know what the word ‘void’ [hadr] means [in Islamic jurisprudence]? It means it is the right for anyone who meets them [those who insult Islam] to kill them.”
Simply put, the host was wrong to think that those who insult Islam should only be killed by the state. Any good Muslim can—and should—kill them, wherever he finds them. Of course, with a Muslim Brotherhood president in office, whether those who offend Islam are killed by the state or by Islamic vigilantes becomes somewhat semantic.
Already under President Morsi’s first two months, Islamists have become more emboldened—whether by pressuring women to wear the hijab, killing a Muslim youth for publicly holding hands with his fiancée, or disseminating flyers that call for the total genocide of Egypt’s Christian Copts—flyers that even openly included names and mosque contact points for those Muslims who wish to collect their rewards for killing Christians.
‘Disrespect’ includes asking questions about the origin of Islam:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=grjR7Kw4o-U
Published on Sep 5, 2012 by SDAMatt2a
Michael Coren comments again on Tom Holland’s excellent presentation ‘Islam: The Untold Story,’ in which Holland explores the mutability and imperfection of islam.
Published on Sep 6, 2012 by SDAMatt2a
Robert Spencer’s latest book ‘Did Muhammad Exist?’ is available for Kindle and is a good companion to Tom Holland’s recent Channel 4 documentary ‘Islam: The Untold Story,’ both of which uncover the fallibility of the Koranic narrative.
- Did Muhammad exist? The Blaze interviews Robert Spencer
- Robert Spencer’s Did Muhammad Exist? “a valuable read”